Blog
Houston's revenue caps and the case for budget reform
Two property tax caps, one from Houston voters in 2004 and one from Texas in 2019, shape the budget. The mayor's case for reform and what critics ask.
One sentence in the mayor's letter at the front of the FY2027 budget proposal carries most of the weight. The city, he wrote, "has operated under two revenue caps, forcing a nearly 20 percent reduction in the tax rate while demand for services and infrastructure has continued to grow." Out of that premise the letter builds an argument for what it calls structural reform: a new monthly fee for trash collection, a new rental fee on water and wastewater utilities, and a long-term shift in how the General Fund is paid for. It is a fight about money, and it has more than one side.
What follows lays out what the two caps are, what the mayor argues, what critics and analysts ask and which questions are still open. It takes no side.
The two caps
Two separate rules limit how much property tax revenue Houston can collect, and they work at the same time.
The local cap. In 2004 Houston voters approved Proposition 1, a charter amendment limiting the city's property tax revenues. By the city's Finance Department, the cap is the lower of two numbers: the prior year's cap plus population and inflation growth, or the prior year's revenues plus 4.5 percent. Two years later, in 2006, voters approved Proposition H, which allows $90 million to be added to the base used in the calculation, for public safety purposes. The cap sits in the city charter, so changing it takes another vote of the people.
The state cap. The Texas Legislature passed Senate Bill 2, the Texas Property Tax Reform and Transparency Act of 2019. It changed a lot about how local governments adopt property tax rates, including fewer required public hearings and a faster timeline for adopting a rate. The change that matters most to a city's budget is the one that lowers the rate the city can adopt without triggering a voter election: the multiplier dropped from 8 percent to 3.5 percent, a smaller allowed rise in revenue each year, with a further reduction for property value under appeal.
The Finance Department's own history of the caps says Houston was first affected by the local cap in fiscal year 2015 and by the state cap in fiscal year 2021. Both times the effect was a year-over-year decrease in the property tax rate. The lowest of all the applicable limits governs in any year, which is why the mayor's letter speaks of "dual" caps. The city adopted a property tax rate of 0.51919 per $100 of value for tax year 2025, made up of 0.40326 for maintenance and operations and 0.11593 for debt.
What the mayor argues
The case in the budget letter has four parts.
- The caps cut into the General Fund over time. The letter says Houston continues "to operate under one of the most restrictive revenue environments in the country due to both local and state-imposed caps." Property tax is 48 percent of General Fund revenue, projected at $1.50 billion for FY2027, with growth of 3.5 percent, and sales tax is 30.1 percent, at $942.2 million with growth of 2.3 percent. When the biggest source of money grows slowly by law, the argument runs, the city has to find other ways to pay for services whose costs grow on their own.
- Other cities do it differently. The letter says Houston operated for years "without dedicated funding for solid waste, without standard right-of-way charges, and under dual revenue caps," and that peer cities use the standard practices Houston did not. It calls a right-of-way fee on water and wastewater "standard practice across major Texas cities, which typically charge between 4% and 14% of gross revenues."
- Credit rating agencies agree on the risk. The letter says the agencies have identified three major structural risks: pension liabilities, other post-employment benefits and the revenue cap.
- The reforms keep the tax rate where it is. The budget presents its new revenue as a way to avoid raising the property tax rate. The Finance Department told the council in October 2025 that the city was not proposing a rate increase, and gave a sense of scale: at the time, a one-cent increase would cost the average homestead homeowner about $2.85 a month, and an average homeowner over 65 about $0.68, using an assumed home value of $342,000.
The numbers the letter attaches to its reforms are $116 million in General Fund relief from moving Solid Waste into the Combined Utility System, and $104 million in new revenue from the right-of-way fee, together "approximately $220 million in structural improvement." Both are explained in detail in moving trash to a utility, the solid waste fee decision and The right-of-way fee on Houston water and wastewater. The letter describes the closing aim as "putting Houston on equal footing with our peers."
The letter is blunt about the stakes. "Absent reform," it says, "the General Fund is not sustainable."
What critics and analysts ask
Reform proposals draw questions from several directions, and a fair reading includes them.
Is the cap really the cause? A policy analysis from Rice University's Baker Institute argues the caps are not the main reason Houston has budget trouble. It notes that property tax revenue has grown faster than population and inflation even under the limits, and points instead to other pressures on spending. Defenders of the mayor's position answer that the caps still bind in the years when property values jump, forcing the rate down, and that the relevant comparison is with what the city's costs have done.
Do the fees replace a tax or add to it? The city's budget proposal page calls the solid waste charge "a use-based fee, not a tax," and says it creates dedicated funding for trash service and eases pressure on the property tax rate. A resident who spots a new line on a monthly utility bill may see a new charge on top of the property tax. The fee is $5 a month on households that get city curbside service, and it sits alongside the container lease fee already on the bill. The caps apply to property tax revenue, and a fee is a different category of revenue, a distinction supporters of reform treat as the reason fees are a legitimate response and skeptics treat as a way around the voters' limit.
Why not ask the voters to lift the local cap? The local cap is a charter provision, and Houston voters have amended it once before, with Proposition H in 2006. The FY2027 plan leaves the property tax rate where it is and looks to other revenue instead. A cap raised by voters would carry the authority of an election. The state cap is set in state law, though, and only the Legislature can change it. That is why a city-only vote cannot remove both.
How does Houston compare? In an October 2025 presentation the Finance Department compared the city's rate with those of four other large Texas cities: Houston's adopted rate was 51.919 cents per $100 of value, against 70.470 in Dallas, 47.760 in Austin, 67.250 in Fort Worth and 76.141 in El Paso. The presentation also showed the average homestead tax bill at each city's rate: $1,668 in Houston on an average taxable value of $321,303, against $2,450 in Dallas, $2,417 in Austin, $1,596 in Fort Worth and $1,559 in El Paso, each on its own average taxable value. Keep in mind the figures are city taxes only, on homes of different values, so they show a pattern and do not rank the cities.
Do the new revenues grow? Property tax revenue is capped in its growth. A right-of-way fee set as a percentage of utility revenue would rise as utility revenue rises. The mayor's letter describes a starting rate of 5 percent, at the low end of the range it cites. Critics ask whether the rate will stay there, and supporters note that a change in the percentage would be a council decision.
What the caps do not touch
It helps to be clear about what the caps leave alone. They limit how much property tax revenue the city can collect. They do not limit sales tax, and they do not apply to the water and sewer system, which customer rates pay for. Nor do they change who sets the tax rate: the council sets the rate each year after the Harris Central Appraisal District, a separate body, values property, and the Harris County Tax Office collects the bill. The steps in a homeowner's bill are in Reading your Harris County property tax bill.
That distinction is one reason the budget letter leans so hard on sources other than property tax. If the cap bites on one kind of revenue, the argument for reform is to look at the others.
The open questions
A few matters the letter and the debate do not settle:
- Will voters be asked about the local cap? Changing it takes a charter amendment, and the city's own process for putting those on the ballot is described in How Houston voters amend the city charter.
- How will the new fees perform? The budget estimates $116 million and $104 million. Whether actual results match depends on the year ahead, and the controller's monthly reports and the council's Budget and Fiscal Affairs committee are where results get checked, as covered in The controller's office, Houston's chief financial officer.
- What happens to the $25 million? The proposal says the projected gap of $209 million was cut to $25 million. How the remainder gets closed is part of the year's work.
- What does it mean for the pension liability? The mayor's letter puts the city's pension liability at $1.7 billion and says the budget maintains responsible contributions. A separate piece, The city pension liability in the FY2027 budget, takes that up.
How to follow it
The budget numbers are on the city's budget page, and the Finance Department's presentations to the council's committees are posted on the council's committee pages. The topline figures for the year are collected in Inside the FY2027 Houston budget in numbers. A resident with a stake in the argument, on either side, can speak at the council's Tuesday public session, using the sign-up process described in Attending and speaking at Houston City Council.