Blog

The city pension liability in the FY2027 budget

Houston's $1.7 billion pension liability, the three separate pension boards, the 2017 reform that capped city costs, and why the debt still shapes each budget.

Buried in the mayor's message on the fiscal year 2027 budget is a line that puts the city's pension liability at $1.7 billion. It sits in a short list of burdens the budget has to carry: two revenue caps, a gap that shrank from $209 million to about $25 million, and a rainy-day cushion of $273.8 million. That one line hides a long story, because Houston does not run one pension plan. It runs three, each with its own board, its own investments and its own history of arguing with City Hall.

Here is who owes what to whom, what the Legislature did in 2017, how the lawsuits that followed settled, and where the pension debt turns up when you read the budget.

Three systems, three boards

Houston's employees are not in one retirement plan. Three separate systems hold the money and pay the benefits:

  • The Houston Municipal Employees Pension System (HMEPS) covers the civilian workforce: the people in Public Works, Solid Waste, the library, the health department, the permitting center and the other non-uniformed departments.
  • The Houston Police Officers' Pension System (HPOPS) covers sworn officers of the Houston Police Department.
  • The Houston Firefighters' Relief and Retirement Fund (HFRRF) covers firefighters.

Each has its own board of trustees, its own staff and a website where members and the public can read annual reports. The Finance Department's page lists all three and links to a separate page on pension reform. The city is the employer that sends contributions to each system, but it does not control how the boards invest, and it does not set benefits by itself. Benefits for these systems are set in state law, which is why a change in Houston's pension rules has to go through Austin, as it did in 2017.

That structure is why pension politics in Houston has so often been a three-cornered conversation among the mayor, the council and the boards, with the state Legislature as referee.

What "unfunded" means

A pension fund is "unfunded" to the degree that the money set aside, plus expected investment earnings, falls short of the benefits already promised. The shortfall is a liability, and like any debt it has to be paid down over time. If the city pays too little in a given year, the shortfall grows with interest.

Before 2017, Houston's own description of the problem was blunt: the real unfunded liability across the three systems stood at $8.2 billion. The city had also borrowed more than $1 billion from the pension systems over the years, which made the hole deeper. The Finance Department's pension reform page tells the story in a timeline that begins with a mayoral press conference on October 25, 2016, and ends, for now, with court rulings in 2019 and 2022.

The 2017 reform

The reform came in two parts, and the second needed voters.

The legislative deal. In early 2017 the city and employee groups brought a negotiated agreement to the Texas Legislature, and the Legislature passed it. Its main features, as the city describes them:

  1. Closed amortization. The debt is now paid off over a fixed 30 years, like a mortgage, instead of an "open" schedule that restarted the clock and never retired the balance.
  2. A realistic return assumption. The systems use a 7 percent assumed rate of return.
  3. Gains and losses recognized. The pension boards have to recognize all investment gains and losses rather than smoothing them away.
  4. A set contribution method. The city's contribution rate is calculated each year through a Risk Sharing Valuation Study. When investments underperform by a wide margin, a "cost corridor" caps what the city has to add: the boards cut benefits or raise employee contributions instead.
  5. Full and on-time payments. The city must make its pension payments in full.

The city described the package as budget neutral, with no new taxes needed to carry it.

The bonds. The second part was a pension obligation bond. In November 2017 Houston voters approved the bonds by about three to one, with more than 75 percent in favor. The city finished issuing them by the end of that year. The money repaid the more than $1 billion the city had borrowed from the systems, which put the plans on firmer ground before the new payment rules took over.

A mortgage, in numbers

The 30-year closed schedule is the easiest part of the reform to picture. Take an invented debt of $1,000,000 at 7 percent, repaid in equal annual payments over 30 years. The payment works out to about $80,586 a year. Over 30 years that adds up to roughly $2.42 million paid to retire a $1 million balance. The debt shrinks every year, but the interest on the unpaid part is why the total runs to more than double the principal.

This is a simplified picture (the actual schedules are set by the systems' actuaries, and contributions follow the cost-corridor rules above), but it shows why a closed schedule matters. Under an open schedule the clock keeps restarting, so a payment that looks like it is "paying down" the debt may only cover the interest. Under a closed schedule there is an end date.

The lawsuits

The 2017 law did not end the argument. The firefighters' board challenged parts of the reform in court. The sequence, from the city's own timeline:

  • June 20, 2019: a state appeals court sided with the city in a lawsuit over the reform.
  • Late 2020: the firefighters' pension board won a ruling that put part of the reform in doubt.
  • August 31, 2022: an appeals court reversed that ruling and upheld the reform.

If you think of a pension fix as a single vote, this history is a good corrective. A reform that needs the Legislature, the voters, three boards and, in this case, the courts can take years to settle.

Where the liability sits in the FY2027 budget

Houston's fiscal year runs from July 1 to June 30, and FY2027 began July 1, 2026. The mayor's proposal totaled $7.5 billion across all funds and $3.16 billion in the General Fund, which pays for public safety, the library, parks and most day-to-day services. The $1.7 billion pension liability is not a line item in that General Fund spending; it is a measure of what is still owed. What shows up in the budget is the city's annual contribution to the systems and the debt service on the 2017 bonds.

Public safety is where the pension question touches the most people. In the mayor's proposal, police and fire accounted for $2 billion, or 75.3 percent of General Fund spending once debt service and pay-as-you-go capital are set aside. Pension contributions for uniformed workers rise with payroll, so a pay raise is a pension cost too. For the raises and the cadet classes in the same budget, see The FY2027 pay raises and cadet classes, in numbers; for how the larger budget fits together, Inside the FY2027 Houston budget in numbers.

The caps that squeeze the rest

Houston's revenue can rise only so fast. The mayor's message refers to "dual revenue caps." With revenue limited and pension payments fixed by law, the room left for everything else is what gets fought over every spring. The case for and against changing the caps is laid out in houston's revenue caps and the case for budget reform, and the way the General Fund is financed (48 percent from property tax, 30.1 percent from sales tax in the FY2027 proposal) is in How the Houston General Fund is paid for.

What the credit agencies watch

Bond rating agencies read a city's budget the way a lender reads a loan application. Coverage of Houston's FY2027 budget in the municipal bond press points to three structural concerns: the pension liabilities, the cost of retiree benefits other than pensions, and the revenue cap. A better rating lowers what the city pays to borrow for streets, drainage and buildings; a worse one raises it. That is why the pension number matters to residents who never think about retirement systems: the interest rate on the next drainage bond depends partly on it.

The city's elected Controller certifies the money before the council commits it and reviews the city's finances independently, a different job from the mayor's. See Office of the City Controller for what the office does and The controller's office, Houston's chief financial officer for how its warnings differ from the mayor's proposals.

Checking the numbers yourself

You do not have to take a columnist's word for any of this. The primary documents are public:

  1. The city's budget pages. The Finance Department posts the budget, the Budget in Brief and the five-year plan. The Budget in Brief includes the mayor's message, which is where the $1.7 billion figure and the other budget pressures appear. The budget page is at houstontx.gov/budget.
  2. The pension reform page. The city keeps its timeline and a summary of the reform at houstontx.gov/pensions.
  3. The three systems' websites. HMEPS, HPOPS and HFRRF each publish annual reports and actuarial valuations. These show the funded ratio of each plan and the assumptions behind it.
  4. A public records request. If a document is not posted, the Texas Public Information Act lets you ask for it in writing. The steps are in Requesting public records from the City of Houston, and the rules around open meetings and records are in Public Records and Open Meetings.

When you read a figure, check what it is measuring and when. A liability is a snapshot at a valuation date; a contribution is what the city pays in a fiscal year; a funded ratio compares assets with promised benefits at a point in time. Mixing them up is the most common way a pension story goes wrong.

Why it matters if you never worked for the city

For a household with no city paycheck, the pension debt shows up four ways. It competes with services for General Fund dollars, because pension payments are not optional. It affects the city's credit rating and therefore the cost of borrowing. It is part of the argument for and against raising the revenue caps, which would change how much the city can collect from property owners. And it is why a pay raise for uniformed employees costs more than the paycheck.

None of that decides whether the 2017 reform worked. By the city's own account it replaced an open-ended problem with a fixed schedule and a cap. Whether a given year's contribution is high or low relative to need is a question the actuaries answer every year, and the answer is in the valuation studies above.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic