Blog

The right-of-way fee on Houston water and wastewater

How the 5 percent right-of-way rental fee in the FY2027 budget works, what $104 million implies, how it differs from a water rate, and what both sides ask.

Under every Houston street there is a second city, made of pipe. Water mains carry treated water to the taps. Sewers carry wastewater away. Gas lines, electric conduit and telecommunications cable share the same corridors. The strip of public land they all run through is called the right-of-way, and it belongs to the public, with the city in charge. In the FY2027 budget, Houston proposed a new charge for using it: a rental fee on the city's own water and wastewater utilities, set at 5 percent of their gross revenues, which the budget counts on for $104 million in new General Fund revenue.

That is a small phrase in a long budget, and it is easy to get wrong. The fee is charged to the utility, not the customer, and it is not a rate. Here is what it is, how the arithmetic works, and why the idea draws both support and questions.

What a right-of-way fee is

Call it rent. A utility that puts its facilities in public streets and easements pays the public owner for the land. The city's budget proposal page puts it in everyday terms: utilities "compensate the City" for using public streets, the way a business that takes up street space, a valet lane say, pays for it. The page adds that other utilities already pay similar fees to the city and names three: CenterPoint, AT&T and Comcast.

The new part in FY2027 is that the city's own water and wastewater utility sits on the paying side. Houston Public Works runs the utility, serves more than 2.3 million residents according to the department, and the budget treats it as part of the Combined Utility System. The recipient is the General Fund, the part of the budget that pays for police, fire, parks and libraries. The proposal shifts money from the utility side of the books to the General Fund side as rent for the streets the pipes sit under.

The mayor's budget letter puts the step this way: the budget "includes $104 million in new General Fund revenue through a right-of-way fee on water and wastewater utilities. This is a standard practice across major Texas cities, which typically charge between 4% and 14% of gross revenues. Houston will begin at a conservative 5% rate."

The arithmetic

Three numbers define the fee: the rate, the base and the yield. The rate is 5 percent. The yield is $104 million. The base is the gross revenue of the water and wastewater utilities, and you can back it out from the other two.

  • $104 million divided by 0.05 is about $2.08 billion. If the fee brings in $104 million at 5 percent, the revenue it applies to runs on the order of $2.1 billion a year.

That figure is an inference from the budget's own numbers, not one the letter states, but it shows how large the water and wastewater business is. The same base shows what the range in the letter would mean. As an illustration only, not a proposal:

Rate Yield on a $2.08 billion base
4 percent about $83 million
5 percent (the FY2027 rate) $104 million
14 percent about $291 million

The table is plain multiplication. It shows why the mayor's letter calls 5 percent "conservative": the fee starts at the low end of the range the letter gives for other Texas cities. The city's budget proposal page puts the yield at about $100 million a year, in line with the $104 million in the letter.

Fee versus rate

The usual mix-up is between this fee and a water rate. Different things, charged to different parties.

A water rate is what a customer pays for water and wastewater service. It shows up on the monthly bill, it comes out of the utility's rate process, and it covers the cost of treating, delivering and collecting water. Customers can read the current charges on the city's water bill pages, and the household side is covered in Start water service and read your Houston water bill.

A right-of-way fee is what the utility pays the city for using public land. For the utility it is a cost of doing business, the same as the check CenterPoint or a cable company writes. It gets no line of its own on a customer's bill. How a utility's costs, rent included, feed into the rates customers pay is a question for the rate-setting process, and the city's water bill pages and notices explain the current charges.

So no household gets a right-of-way bill. The household sees the effect, if there is one, in the rates the utility sets.

Two ways to picture the size of it

Start with a dollar of utility revenue. At 5 percent, five cents of every dollar of gross revenue goes from the utility to the General Fund, and the other ninety-five cents stays with the water and wastewater system. The fee takes a slice of revenue, not of profit. It is figured on gross revenues, which is why the letter says "gross revenues" and why a utility with heavy costs still owes it.

Now spread the yield across the city. The FY2027 booklet gives Houston's population as 2,392,327. Divide $104 million by that and the fee comes to about $43 per resident per year. That is a way of seeing the scale of the General Fund's new income, not a charge on anyone's bill. Set it against the General Fund as a whole, about $1,320 per resident, and the fee is a few percent of the total.

The corridor itself is vast. The city covers about 672 square miles, and Houston Public Works answers for streets, drainage, water and wastewater, and engineering across all of it, including programs such as the Roadside Ditch Re-establishment Program that deal with drainage in the same public land. Houston Public Works describes the department.

Why cities do it

The case for a fee like this has several layers.

  1. The street has a cost. Pipes in the street are not free to the city. The city maintains the pavement, issues the permits for cutting into it and manages the underground corridor. The Houston Permitting Center handles right-of-way permits and street cuts, and digging for a water line is exactly the work those permits cover.
  2. Private utilities already pay. If an electric delivery company, a phone company and a cable company all pay rent for the streets, the argument goes, a utility the city owns should not get different treatment.
  3. It diversifies revenue. The mayor's letter describes Houston as operating under two caps on property tax revenue, one set by local voters in 2004 and one set by the state in 2019. A fee on utilities sits outside those caps, since they limit property tax revenue and not other sources. houston's revenue caps and the case for budget reform explains the caps.
  4. Peers do it. The letter says other major Texas cities charge between 4 and 14 percent, and the budget presents the change as lining Houston up with them.

The questions it raises

A fee that moves money from one corner of the city's books to another invites obvious questions, and a fair account has to include them.

Is it a real new resource or a transfer? The water and wastewater utility is part of the city, so a payment from the utility to the General Fund moves money inside city government. Supporters answer that this is what a right-of-way fee does everywhere: the utility is a separate enterprise with its own revenue, and the General Fund is the party that owns and maintains the streets. Skeptics ask what the utility gives up to pay it, whether that is capital work or a rate increase.

Where does the utility find the money? Whether the utility's revenue grows enough to carry a new 5 percent charge without pressure on rates is something the year's results will show. The controller's monthly reports and the council's budget committee are where such results get reviewed, as The controller's office, Houston's chief financial officer explains.

Will the rate stay at 5 percent? The letter calls it a starting point. Changing it would take a council decision, so the percentage would be debated in public on a posted agenda. Anyone who wants to weigh in has the Tuesday public session described in A Houston council week, Tuesday public session to Wednesday votes.

How does it sit beside the other reform? The same budget moves Solid Waste into the Combined Utility System and sets a $5 monthly fee on households with city curbside service. Together the two are what the letter calls "approximately $220 million in structural improvement": $116 million in relief and $104 million in new revenue. The solid waste decision gets its own account in moving trash to a utility, the solid waste fee decision.

Where water customers fit

Houston Public Works has been working on the customer side of the water system through what it calls the Water Bill Improvement Plan. A resident with a question about a water bill, as opposed to the city's budget, is better served by the department's own pages and by the history in the water bill problem and the improvement plan. The two stories run side by side: one is about how the utility charges its customers, the other about what the utility pays the city.

Reading the number in context

The $104 million sits inside a General Fund of $3.16 billion. That is about 3.3 percent of the total ($104 million divided by $3.16 billion). It is a meaningful sum, as the budget treats it, and also one piece of a much larger plan, which Inside the FY2027 Houston budget in numbers lays out in numbers.

The takeaways fit in a few lines. The right-of-way fee is rent paid by the city's water and wastewater utility to the General Fund for the use of public streets. It starts at 5 percent of the utility's gross revenue. It is expected to yield $104 million, and the letter proposing it says other Texas cities charge between 4 and 14 percent. It is not on your water bill, and it is not your water rate.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic