Blog

The Menil Collection and the Rothko Chapel, a Montrose district built by two collectors

How Dominique and John de Menil built a chapel in 1971 and a Renzo Piano gallery in 1987, and turned a few Montrose blocks into one of Houston's art districts.

You could drive past the Menil Collection and not know you had missed a major museum. That was the idea. The building is low and gray-sided, trimmed in white, with black awnings, and it sits among gray bungalows in Montrose as if it had been there all along. Dominique de Menil asked for a building that was small on the outside and big on the inside, and she got it. A few blocks away is a brick chapel with no windows, fourteen enormous dark paintings, a sculpture in a reflecting pool dedicated to Martin Luther King, Jr., and a long record of hosting prayer, scholarship and protest. Both exist because two people with plenty of money and an unusual supply of patience decided, in the second half of the twentieth century, to build them in Houston.

The collectors

Dominique and John de Menil started collecting art in Europe in 1931, soon after they married. They moved to Houston in 1941, when John became head of Schlumberger's Houston office, and they never left. Schlumberger is an oilfield services company, so the couple's arrival is part of the same story as the energy money that paid for a surprising share of Houston's culture. In the late 1940s they hired the architect Philip Johnson to design their house in River Oaks, a modernist home in a neighborhood known mostly for revival styles. Neighbors could have guessed what was coming: the Menils meant to bring Houston an idea of art and architecture well ahead of local taste.

By the time John died in 1973, the couple had gathered more than 10,000 works. The range is what stands out. Ancient and tribal art, Byzantine objects, and the surrealists and modern artists the Menils had known personally all share the shelves. Dominique lived until 1997 and carried the project through its most visible years.

The Rothko Chapel

The chapel came first, and it started life as part of something bigger. Philip Johnson had been designing a campus for the University of St. Thomas, the Catholic university in Montrose established in 1945, and a chapel was meant to be part of it. When the Menils ended their association with the university, the chapel became a project of its own, on Yupon Street.

The painter Mark Rothko made the paintings and worked with Johnson on the structure. The building is an octagon without windows. Inside hang fourteen paintings on eight panels: three of the wall panels are triptychs, the south wall holds a single canvas, and four canvases sit on the diagonal axes. The palette is deep brown, purplish red and black. The paintings are not pictures of anything. They are broad fields of dark color, and they shift as your eyes adjust to the light.

Stand inside for a few minutes and the room does its work slowly. There is nothing to read and nothing to identify, only the long walls of dark canvas, and the eye keeps searching for an edge or a figure and not finding one. The room asks for patience more than knowledge, which is why it works for visitors who have no interest in art history at all.

Rothko died in 1970 and never saw the finished room. The chapel went up in 1971. Light came through a skylight Rothko had insisted on, and it turned out to light the paintings poorly, so baffles went in during 1978 to fix it. The Rothko Chapel Board owns and directs the building, and Dominique de Menil served as its president.

The Broken Obelisk and the interfaith record

Facing the chapel door, in a reflecting pool, stands Barnett Newman's Broken Obelisk: 26 feet tall, an obelisk flipped upside down with its point balanced on the tip of a pyramid. John de Menil bought it in 1968 and dedicated it to Martin Luther King, Jr., who was assassinated that year. The sculpture ties the chapel's quiet to a moment of national violence, and from the earliest days it gave the place a link to the civil rights movement.

Nobody meant the chapel to be only an art space. Many faiths have worshiped there, and so have people with none. The Whirling Dervishes of Turkey came in 1978, the Dalai Lama in September 1979 and the Gyuto Tantric Monks of Tibet in 1985. A colloquium in July 1973 on contemplation and action gathered nineteen scholars and produced a book on the subject across world religions. An October 1983 colloquium on ethnicities and nations led to a volume on relations among peoples. Since 1981 the chapel has given awards for commitment to truth and freedom; in 1988 the Second Oscar Romero Award went to Paulo Evaristo Cardinal Arns of Brazil. It is an unusual résumé for a room whose centerpiece is abstract painting, and it explains why people call the chapel an interfaith sanctuary.

The Menil Collection opens

The museum followed sixteen years later, opening to the public on June 7, 1987. It stands on nine city blocks in Montrose and was designed by the Italian architect Renzo Piano with Richard Fitzgerald and Partners. The engineer Peter Rice worked on the lighting.

The particulars show how a big museum can be made to feel like a house. The main building is 40 feet wide and 142 feet long, with a maximum height of 45 feet. Roughly 300 ferro-cement leaves hang from the ceiling and filter natural light, shaped so daylight comes in and direct sun stays off the art. Outside, gray wood siding, white trim and black canvas awnings let the place melt into the bungalow blocks. Mrs. Menil's instruction, small outside and big inside, shaped every choice.

No more than 5 percent of the collection is on view at a time. That tells you how the place works. It is built for sustained looking at a few objects, with the rest in storage for research and rotation. A visitor sees only a slice of the holdings, and the slice is the design.

The money problem of 1989

A museum built on one family's gift has to outlast the gift. In 1989 the Menil Collection ran into financial trouble, and the cure was a $35 million endowment, of which $17.5 million came from Mrs. Menil. That turned a family project into an institution able to outlive its founders. Dominique de Menil lived another eight years and watched it work.

A campus, not a building

The Menil has grown the way a village does, one small building at a time, at the same scale as the first. The campus now covers 30 acres. The Cy Twombly Gallery, also by Piano, opened in 1995. The Byzantine Fresco Chapel, designed by Dominique's son François de Menil, opened in 1997. In 1996 Dominique de Menil commissioned a Dan Flavin installation, which opened in Richmond Hall in 1998. The Menil Drawing Institute was created in 2008, and ground was broken for its building on March 27, 2015. Bistro Menil opened in 2014.

Every addition keeps the low roofline and leaves the green space alone. Walk the grounds and you pass small buildings and lawns, closer to a village than to a museum complex. That scale sets the Menil apart from other major American museums, and it is why the Montrose blocks around it feel unlike the rest of the city.

The neighborhood effect

Houston has no zoning, as Why Houston has no zoning and how development is governed instead explains, so the look of the blocks around the Menil came down to the choices of one owner. Plenty of the bungalows nearby wear the museum's own gray and white. Because Montrose is an old neighborhood of small houses, the museum could settle in among them without looming over them. More on the neighborhood is at Montrose and Montrose, between the Menil and the Rothko Chapel.

The Menil also anchors one end of a larger cultural map. The Museum District, home to the Museum of Fine Arts, Houston and several other institutions, is a short distance south. The two districts are cousins, not twins. The Museum District is a set of separate institutions that grew up next to each other. The Menil is one vision, carried out. The difference gets its own treatment in Museum District and The Museum District, seven million visitors a year.

Visiting

Plan for slowness. Neither place rewards a quick pass, and neither is built for a visitor who wants to check off a list of famous names. The walk between them is part of the visit, the gray bungalow blocks included.

The chapel and the Menil campus are separate sites run by separate organizations, a short walk or drive apart, and each posts its own hours on its website. The chapel is for quiet. The museum is for looking. Pair them, and let the walk between take you through the bungalow blocks the Menils kept. For other low-cost ways to see art in the city, see Free things to do in Houston.

Private patrons rarely shape a neighborhood this coherently, and rarer still is doing it without the grand gestures most cultural institutions reach for. In a city that builds tall and fast, the Menil and the Rothko Chapel are where Houston chose to build small and slow.

Related neighborhoods

Related guides

Latest on this topic