Blog

The city manager experiment, 1942 to 1947

Houston ran under a council-appointed city manager for five years, then voted to put an elected mayor back in charge. What changed, and what it left behind.

Nearly every big American city has some kind of mayor-council government, and the details differ more than the labels let on. Houston runs the "strong mayor" version: an elected mayor as chief executive, a council that legislates, and a controller elected on his or her own. It has been that way since 1947. For the five years before, from 1942 to 1947, Houston tried something else. A manager hired by the council ran the city, and the mayor was closer to a presiding officer. The experiment was short, and its short life is a good way to see what the city decided it wanted.

Before 1942

For most of the nineteenth century Houston was governed by aldermen elected by ward, with a mayor presiding over them. The state historical handbook notes that in 1905 the city moved to a modified commission form, in which a small body of officials elected at large replaced the old ward aldermen. The commission system was a national reform of the early twentieth century, and Galveston itself adopted a commission government after the 1900 hurricane. In theory it replaced ward politics with accountable officials. Critics said it left several elected commissioners each running a corner of the city.

By the 1930s reformers in Houston were arguing that the commission arrangement was fragmented. Their proposal was the city manager form: a professional administrator appointed by the council, responsible for hiring and firing department heads and running the day-to-day government. The idea came from the business world. A city was a large corporation, and it ought to have a general manager answerable to a board.

The vote and the 1942 election

Reformers brought the idea forward in 1938 and again in 1941, and the second time voters approved it. In the 1942 election, supporters of the new system ran against the sitting commission and won. The reformers' leader, Otis Massey, became mayor and served as the first mayor under the new arrangement. The incumbent mayor and the entire commission were out. This was no administrative footnote. It was a political upset, and it came in the first year of the war, as the city was starting its great wartime expansion along the Ship Channel, covered in Houston shipbuilding in World War II, from Liberty ships to destroyer escorts.

The state handbook dates the city manager government to the years 1942 to 1947. Under it the council appointed the manager, and the manager answered to the council. That is the core difference from the strong-mayor model. In a city manager system the executive is accountable to the legislature. In a strong-mayor system the executive is accountable to the voters.

What the manager system did

The record of how Houston's manager government actually worked is thinner than the record of how it ended. What the history does make clear is the setting: wartime Houston was growing so fast that its government had to run to catch up. The city had 73 square miles in 1940 and 160 square miles by 1950, as annexation after annexation brought older suburbs inside the limits, work that mostly happened in the years just after the manager system ended. Water, sewer and street demands were enormous. A professional manager was expected to organize all of it.

That expectation is the case for the form, and it is not a bad one. Managers are hired for their skill, can be removed by a majority of the council and do not have to campaign every four years. Many cities that adopted the form in the twentieth century still use it, and Texas has plenty of them. It tends to suit cities where voters want steady administration and are willing to let the council lead on politics.

Why the city went back

The turn came in the 1946 campaign. Houston voters were ready to reject the manager form, and they returned Oscar F. Holcombe to the mayor's office. Holcombe, a veteran of earlier terms, backed the strong-mayor model, and his opponents in that race included a candidate who defended the manager system and a former fire commissioner. The change was written into the city's charter by amendments approved in 1947, which moved the city manager's powers to the mayor. Under the new arrangement, department heads, once confirmed, answered to the mayor, not the council.

The appeal of the strong-mayor model is easy to state. In a manager system the person running the departments is not elected, and a voter unhappy about services or taxes has no single official to vote out. Under the 1947 amendments the executive answered to the electorate. Holcombe's council soon put the new strength to work in the annexations of 1948 and 1949, which absorbed older suburbs. The city grew from 73 to 160 square miles between 1940 and 1950, and in 1956 another annexation vote roughly doubled it again. The politics of that growth are in the annexation wars, 1948 to 1960.

The system that came out of it

The form Houston adopted in 1947 is the one it uses now. The Mayor's Office describes the mayor as the executive officer of the city, responsible for its general management and for seeing that its laws and ordinances are enforced. The mayor appoints department heads and board members, subject to council approval. The mayor also signs motions, resolutions and ordinances, presides over council with a vote, and presents the annual budget. The controller, the chief financial officer, is elected citywide. How those offices split their powers is in Mayor, controller, council, who holds what power in Houston, and the city's own pages for Mayor's Office and Houston City Council describe them in current terms.

After 1947 the bigger changes came in the council, not the executive. In 1979 a ruling from the U.S. Justice Department led the city to elect nine council members from districts and five at large. Two more districts were added in 2011, producing the sixteen-member council of eleven district seats and five at-large seats that sits today. That history is the subject of Sixteen seats, how Houston's council districts came to be. The firsts that followed, such as the first African American council member in 1971 and the first woman mayor in 1981, were possible in a system where voters choose the executive directly.

Four forms, side by side

Houston has lived under several forms of city government, and a comparison shows why the 1942 change and the 1947 reversal were each a real shift in power.

Form Who runs the departments Who the executive answers to Houston years
Aldermen and mayor, elected by ward Aldermen and the mayor Ward voters Nineteenth century
Modified commission A small body of at-large officials Citywide voters From 1905
Council and city manager A professional manager hired by the council The council 1942 to 1947
Strong mayor and council Department heads appointed by the mayor, confirmed by the council The voters, through the mayor From 1947

Read down the third column and the logic shows. Each reform moved the executive a step away from the voters or toward them. The manager form was the most insulated from elections. The strong-mayor form, back in 1947, put an elected executive in direct charge and gave the council a check through confirmation and the budget.

Questions the change still raises

The strong-mayor form has stood for nearly eighty years, and the arguments over it have not gone away. Defenders say a single elected executive is easy to hold responsible. Critics say the system puts a great deal of power in one office and gives the council little role in running departments, which is one reason the council's committees, the controller's audits and the boards and commissions the mayor appoints carry so much weight. The council's weekly meetings show how those checks work in practice. The budget is another place to watch. The mayor proposes the annual budget, and the council votes on it, as described in Inside the FY2027 Houston budget in numbers.

A resident who wants to follow the structure can use the same tools the 1940s reformers wanted voters to have: the council's agendas, which are posted at least three full business days before a meeting, the controller's reports, and the city's public information process. The current form of government is also a reminder that the charter can be changed by a vote of the people, a process described in How Houston voters amend the city charter.

What the experiment left behind

Five years is not long enough to leave a deep mark on a city, and Houston's manager government left fewer visible traces than its wartime shipyards or its annexations did. It left a lesson civic historians still cite. A city can reorganize its government through a charter vote, then reorganize it again when the first design proves unsatisfying, and the voters can be the ones to do it. The 1947 amendments are a city using its own charter powers to change course.

It also left a question that surfaces in Houston whenever city government draws criticism: where does executive power belong? The strong-mayor design gives voters a single person to hold responsible. It also concentrates responsibility in that one person, which is why the council, the controller and the city's boards and commissions matter. The city's own account of how that works is in How Houston city government works. To see the system in action, watch the council's weekly meetings, covered in A Houston council week, Tuesday public session to Wednesday votes.

Related city government

Latest on this topic