Blog
The 1980s oil bust and the only time Houston lost population
How the oil boom of the 1970s turned into a long downturn after 1982, what it cost in jobs, and why diversification is a more complicated story than it sounds.
Houston is a growth story, and the city's own accounts say so decade after decade. There is one exception, and nobody who lived through it forgets it. In the mid-1980s Houston lost population, and the state historical handbook calls it the only time in the city's history that has happened. What broke was the business the city had been built around. Here is what happened, what the record shows about the damage, and the argument that still runs about what "diversification" really meant.
The boom before the fall
The 1970s made Houston a world capital of the energy business. Oil companies and the firms that served them poured in. The Galleria opened in 1970 on Post Oak Boulevard, and the construction boom that followed filled in the skyline. Pennzoil Place went up in 1976, and by 1987 Houston held seven of the state's ten tallest buildings. The Galleria, Pennzoil Place and the 1970s skyline tells that building story. The towers rested on a bet that prices and drilling would keep climbing, and for a decade the bet paid.
A boom like that has a side effect. When the whole economy rests on one commodity, nearly everything in the city's life, from office leasing to restaurants to the number of cars on the freeways, ends up leaning on the price of a barrel of oil. When the price falls, it is felt across the whole city, not just in the oil companies.
1982 to the mid-1980s
Research by the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas dates the peak of Houston's economy to March 1982. Then the economy shrank for years. From peak to trough, Houston lost about 212,000 jobs, close to one in eight nonfarm jobs in the region. Upstream oil employment alone, the work in drilling and the companies that supply rigs, fell by more than 100,000 as the count of working rigs collapsed.
Houston was hit earlier and harder than other Texas cities. The Dallas recession is dated to January 1986, so Houston had been shrinking for years when the rest of the state caught up. The Dallas Fed also noted that Houston's decline and recovery both came during the longest peacetime expansion the nation had yet seen. For Houstonians, the national headlines about good times in the 1980s did not describe the city they lived in.
It was not only a jobs story. A city whose growth had depended on newcomers arriving for energy work found that the arrivals slowed and the departures did not. Those effects ran through the middle of the decade, and they are part of why the decade's population numbers look the way they do. Meanwhile, construction planned during the boom kept opening into the downturn, which a later section covers.
The population record
The state historical handbook says that in the mid-1980s Houston lost population "for the only time in its history." The Census Bureau counts every ten years, and the handbook gives the totals for the decennial years: 1,594,086 in 1980, 1,637,859 in 1990, 1,953,631 in 2000 and 2,100,263 in 2010. Between the 1980 and 1990 counts the city actually grew by a little more than 43,000, and the decade as a whole is a net gain. The loss in the middle of the decade is real in the handbook's account, but it was a dip inside a decade that ended higher than it began.
Keep that straight, because the loss gets repeated as though the 1990 count showed a smaller city. The record shows two things at once: a city that shrank for a few years as people left to look for work, and a city that recovered enough that the next census found more residents than the last. The recovery after 1990 was strong. The 2000 count of 1,953,631 stood about 316,000 above the 1990 count.
The numbers in proportion
A little arithmetic helps. If 212,000 lost jobs was close to one in eight, the regional job base before the downturn was roughly 1.7 million, since 212,000 times eight is about 1.7 million. The upstream oil jobs that disappeared, more than 100,000, were about half of all the jobs lost. The rest came from the businesses that lived off the oil economy: construction, offices, suppliers, retailers.
The recovery has its own arithmetic. The 1990 census count of 1,637,859 was followed by 1,953,631 in 2000. That is an increase of 315,772, a little more than 19 percent in a single decade. A city that had dipped in the 1980s added nearly a fifth to its population in the 1990s, which tells you how much of the earlier loss was a pause and not a verdict.
Did Houston really diversify?
The usual story says Houston learned its lesson, diversified into medicine, space and trade, and is now less tied to the price of oil. There is truth in it, and there are complications, which the economists who studied the period have laid out.
On one side, institutions already in place became more important. The Texas Medical Center, planned in the 1940s on land the city conveyed in 1944, grew into one of the largest employers in the metropolitan area. By 2016 the state handbook reported that it employed 106,000 people. The Johnson Space Center, which NASA built near Clear Lake after the 1961 decision, and the aerospace firms around it provided another source of work. Dallas Fed researchers pointed to both as sources of diversification in the downturn. The history of the center is in NASA and the making of Space City, and the medical complex is covered in Texas Medical Center.
On the other side, the Dallas Fed has also argued that Houston did less to reinvent itself than the slogan suggests. In that reading, the city built on strengths it already had before the boom: refining, chemicals, business services and heavy construction. These industries are kin to oil but behave differently. Refiners and chemical makers are downstream businesses that buy oil and natural gas liquids as their chief feedstock, so low prices can help them even when low prices hurt the producers. A city with both upstream and downstream industries had a hedge against the swings, and that hedge may have mattered more than any new industry.
A fair reading is that both accounts are partly right. Medicine and aerospace gave the economy more weight outside energy. The chemical and refining base gave it resilience inside energy. And the downturn made it harder for anyone in the city to assume that energy alone would carry it.
What opened during the bust
Some of the city's grandest public buildings opened in the middle of the downturn, because they had been planned in the boom. The George R. Brown Convention Center opened in 1987. So did the Wortham Theater Center, the $72 million home of the Houston Grand Opera and Houston Ballet, with about $70 million of that coming from private sources, and so did the Menil Collection. The Astrodome was renovated in 1988 and 1989 at a cost of $100 million, which added seating and luxury boxes. These projects were less a sign that the city had stopped suffering than a reminder that large civic buildings take years to plan and outlast the cycle that launched them.
The Astrodome's story is in Building the Astrodome, from the 1958 bond vote to opening night. The point is that a good share of what you see downtown today was commissioned by people who believed in 1980 that the boom would go on.
Politics in the bust
The downturn overlapped with a change in city government. Houston elected its first woman mayor in 1981, early in the decline, and the city's finances and its sense of itself were tested in the years after. This post takes no position on how city leaders handled it. What the record shows is that the city kept building its institutions, kept annexing land in the form of the Kingwood fight that ended in 1996, and kept electing mayors who talked about growth. The firsts of the era are collected in Firsts at Houston City Hall, from 1971 to 2009.
What it means now
Houston's economy is still tied to energy. Greater Houston is home to the headquarters of major energy and chemical companies, and the Port of Houston and the Ship Channel carry the cargo that comes with them. What changed after the bust is mostly weight. The Texas Medical Center employs more than 100,000 people, the Johnson Space Center and its contractors anchor the southeast side, and the region's universities, hospitals and port give it a second and third set of legs. When prices fall now, the city feels it, but the region has more to fall back on than it did in 1982.
For the current picture, The Houston job market and the energy economy describes what employers are hiring in, and the city's economic development office describes its incentive tools at Economic development and incentives. The lesson of the 1980s is not that Houston should steer clear of energy. It is that a city able to raise office towers on a commodity forecast ought to build a hospital district, a space program and a port while it can afford to.