Blog
Subsidence districts and the water below Houston
Why pumping groundwater made Houston-area land sink, and how subsidence districts and a switch to surface water changed who may drill and how much.
Stand at Allen's Landing, where Buffalo Bayou meets White Oak Bayou, and the ground looks as solid as any other ground in Texas. It is not as solid as it was. Over the twentieth century, parts of the Houston region settled by feet rather than inches, and the reason was underneath: a stack of clay and sand that held water, and a city that pumped that water out faster than the rain could put it back.
That is subsidence, and it explains a surprising amount about Houston. It is why the region has agencies most residents have never heard of, why the city's water comes largely from surface reservoirs rather than wells, and why a flood on a street near the bayou can be a little worse than the old maps promised. It is also why the Houston City Council's own list of appointed boards includes two groundwater bodies, the Fort Bend Subsidence District and the Lone Star Groundwater Conservation District, listed beside the Ethics Commission and the Independent Police Oversight Board on the city's boards page.
What actually sinks
Houston sits on the Gulf Coastal Plain, a flat, wet country built from sediment that rivers laid down over a very long time. Below the surface are layers of sand and gravel that hold water, separated by layers of clay. Water in the sand layers helps hold the whole stack up, the way water in a sponge keeps the sponge from collapsing under your hand.
Pump the water out and the pressure inside the layers falls. The sand barely cares. The clay does: it gives up its own water slowly and compacts, and it does not spring back when the pumping stops or the water returns. The loss is permanent. At the surface, the result is that the ground drops, and it drops across a wide area, so that a house or a street may sink with its neighbors and nobody sees a crack.
Nobody notices subsidence the way they notice a pothole. Where it shows up is in the details: a bayou bank that sits lower than it did, a road that now floods where it once did not, a brick foundation that has shifted, a stretch of waterfront where the tide now reaches farther. The Texas Historical Association's account of Houston describes the region's twentieth-century growth in terms of oil, shipping and refineries. All of that industry, and the residents who came with it, needed water, and for most of the century the cheapest place to get it was the aquifer under their feet.
Industry along the Ship Channel
The heaviest pumping was not in the neighborhoods but along the Houston Ship Channel, the 52-mile waterway Port Houston describes as running from the turning basin out toward the bay. Refineries and chemical plants use enormous volumes of water for cooling and processing. By the middle of the century, industrial wells in the east side of the region were among the biggest drawers on the aquifer, and the east side is where the sinking was worst. In places near the channel and the bay, the land dropped by several feet.
That matters more near the coast than inland. Land that is a few feet above the tide to begin with does not have much to give. Lower the ground and the same storm surge reaches farther, and rain that used to drain toward the bay has less slope to run on. The result is a loss of margin, and margin is what a coastal plain with clay soil runs on. Hurricane Ike and the Houston bay area describes what the bay's water can do, and the floods of 1929 and 1935 and the reservoirs they led to covers the floods that first pushed the region toward large public flood works.
The switch to surface water
The fix had two parts, and the first is easy to say. Stop pulling so much water from underground, and bring water in from somewhere else.
The "somewhere else" is the surface. The city of Houston draws much of its water from rivers and reservoirs rather than from wells, and the plan behind that choice is the subject of The city's water supply, from Trinity and San Jacinto reservoirs. The history of how the city got there is told in sinking ground, subsidence and the switch to surface water. Houston Public Works runs the water and wastewater system, and Houston Public Works describes the department that delivers it to residents. The service is billed monthly, and the bill is explained in Start water service and read your Houston water bill.
A surface-water system solves the sinking problem only if enough of the region uses it. A city can buy surface water, but a subdivision with its own well, a factory with its own well, or a neighboring municipality that pumps from the aquifer can still draw the ground down. That is where the second part comes in.
The districts
Texas gives groundwater a different legal footing from surface water. The state's rule of capture, long the basis of Texas groundwater law, let a landowner pump from under his own land, and for most of the state the modern answer to the problems that rule created has been the groundwater conservation district: a local body created under state law with the authority to manage pumping in its territory.
In the Houston region, the districts that matter most to subsidence are the subsidence districts, which regulate pumping specifically to stop the ground from sinking. Their usual tools are the ones you would expect:
- Permits. Anyone who wants to drill a well that pumps more than a set amount generally has to apply for a permit, and the permit sets how much may be taken.
- Conversion. Large users in regulated areas are expected to move a share of their water supply to surface water or other alternatives, on a schedule. The percentage and the dates differ by district and change over time, and the district sets them.
- Fees. A district may charge for groundwater withdrawal and for conversion to alternatives, and the fees pay for the monitoring and administration, and can nudge a big user toward the alternative.
- Monitoring. Districts watch water levels and land elevation, so that the rules respond to the data rather than to a calendar.
The city's boards page lists the Fort Bend Subsidence District and the Lone Star Groundwater Conservation District, and that is not an accident of paperwork. Houston's boundaries reach into Fort Bend and Montgomery counties, and the territory a district regulates is a matter of geography, not of the city limits. A resident in a Houston address that crosses a county line can be inside a different district than a neighbor a few blocks away. The district for any particular address is the district for that county or portion of a county, and each district's own page states its territory and its rules. For Fort Bend County, the Fort Bend Subsidence District covers the county; for Montgomery County, the Lone Star Groundwater Conservation District does the work, from its base to the north, in the area around Conroe and The Woodlands.
The two districts differ in emphasis because the aquifers and the problems differ. The southeast, near the Ship Channel, is where the sinking has been the heaviest, and it has the longest regulatory history. Montgomery County's concern is water supply and its long-term availability as the region grows. Both districts rest on the same basic idea: the water below is a shared resource, and a shared resource needs a manager.
Who does what
It helps to keep the responsibilities apart, because people often blur them.
- The city (Houston Public Works) sells and delivers treated water to its customers, mostly from surface sources. It does not regulate the private wells in the region.
- A subsidence or groundwater district regulates pumping from the aquifer. It does not deliver water to homes. Its customers are well owners and the entities that pump on a large scale.
- The county flood control district manages bayous, channels and basins. Harris County Flood Control District describes the Harris County Flood Control District, created by the Legislature in 1937. It does not regulate pumping, but its work is affected when the ground it drains drops.
- The city's Planning and Development Department manages platting and development rules inside Houston and its extraterritorial jurisdiction. Planning and Development Department describes the department. Houston has no zoning, and the department's rules govern how land is subdivided, not what it is used for. Neither the department nor the city's permit system decides how a development gets its water; a developer in a regulated area has to satisfy the districts separately.
How subsidence connects to flooding
Subsidence is not the main cause of Houston floods. The main causes are the ones in Six myths about Houston flooding, checked against the record: flat land, clay soil that drains slowly, intense rain, and a great deal of paved ground. But the sinking land interacts with each of them. A channel designed for a certain slope works less well when the land under part of it has dropped. Floodplain maps are drawn from elevation, and elevation changes. A neighborhood such as Meyerland, which has flooded repeatedly, shows the stakes that sit on top of these questions. Anyone buying near a bayou is better served by the official flood maps and elevation certificates than by a general memory of where a street used to be. Flood preparedness in Houston explains where the maps are.
The point is not that subsidence drowned Houston. It is that a city built on a plain with a few feet of margin cannot afford to give the margin away, and for fifty years the region did give some of it away, one well at a time.
What a resident can do
A resident on the city water system does not have to do anything about subsidence. The water arriving at the tap has already been through the city's system. The questions are for someone who has, or is thinking of drilling, a private well, and for people who live in a neighborhood or district with its own water supply.
- Find the district. The county determines it. If you are in Fort Bend County, start with the Fort Bend Subsidence District; if you are in Montgomery County, start with the Lone Star Groundwater Conservation District; in Harris County, a different regulator applies, and the district's website will say.
- Ask before drilling. A well that pumps above a district's threshold needs a permit, and a permit can come with conversion requirements. A small well for household use may be exempt, and the district's rules say what counts as small.
- Check the supplier. If your home is in a municipal utility district or another special district, the district's own page will say where its water comes from, and the water bill will say who to call.
- Use 311 for city water problems. Leaks, low pressure and main breaks inside Houston go through the city's 311 line. How a Houston 311 request travels from call to closed case follows a request from call to crew.
A short test of the idea
Say a developer builds an industrial park in a regulated part of the region and plans to supply it with a well. The district asks three questions: how much water will the park pump, is there a surface-water source the park can connect to instead, and what percentage of the supply must come from an alternative under the district's rules? The park's water bill, and its permit, depend on the answers. The district does not forbid the park. It sets the terms so that the cost of pulling water from underground is counted, and a share of that cost lands on the one who pumps. Multiply that logic by every factory, subdivision and municipal system in the region, and you have the regulatory structure that has been slowing the sinking for decades.
The land does not rebound. Clay that has compacted stays compacted. What the districts and the surface-water switch buy is time: the chance to hold the line where the ground now sits, and to put the region's flood defenses, floodplain maps and building rules on elevation that stops moving. That is a quieter achievement than a reservoir or a freeway, and it shows up mostly in the absence of a problem. In a city that has had its share of visible ones, that counts.